@JayExci In a vacuum, I wouldn't care because they're largely ineffective placebos, but in the current paradigm, I think they're ceding ground to harmful thought patterns and encouraging weakness as a virtue. https://t.co/FceVcxxcV5
@pomelodeguerre @CasualMisfit @BBCPolitics Research actually finds that trigger warnings prime those who might be triggered to already be upset, so, they do harm and hold back the people they intend to help. Development of learned helplessness and not resi
עוד הוכחה שלא כל מה שנשמע הגיוני ורצוי אכן פועל כך. אנשים "מתאהבים" בכל מיני מושגים ומשתמשים בהם למרות שאינם נתמכים מחקרית (Implicit bias הוא דוגמא נוספת). הנה עוד מחקר שמראה שאפילו על אנשים עם היסטוריה של טראומה, אזהרות טריגר לא משפיעות בכלל. https://t.co
RT @lymanstoneky: Reminder: Trigger warnings do virtually nothing to help people cope with stressful inputs. https://t.co/cdbqUTIjJD
RT @lymanstoneky: Reminder: Trigger warnings do virtually nothing to help people cope with stressful inputs. https://t.co/cdbqUTIjJD
But they can deliver a message intended to restrict free speech.
Reminder: Trigger warnings do virtually nothing to help people cope with stressful inputs. https://t.co/cdbqUTIjJD
@Thiefofhearts @tehemopenguin Also, you're citing studies about trigger warnings in academia. https://t.co/odBzXXzlSq This has absolutely nothing to do with a warning screen in a videogame telling you that if you're bothered by any of these things, you sho
2/2 More research w Sanson @drlambchop @DerynStrange . "people reported similar levels of negative affect, intrusions, and avoidance regardless of whether they had received a trigger warning. ...similar among people with a history of trauma." https://t.co/
@LostMyInhaler @SkookumNewsPDX If you bothered to read the article and the follow up articles and the research linked that is not true. https://t.co/5e40nhwTMt
car ils encourageraient ceux qui lisent le TW à ne pas affronter ce qu'il y a, mais à plutôt l'éviter, au prix d'apprendre à gérer leur détresse d'une autre manière. https://t.co/Po7eoZPFxC (sci-hub est votre ami) 2/3
Uma das pesquisas neste sentido (tem várias): https://t.co/cHmNX6PrE0
@titiatscriptor "Across six experiments, we gave some college students and Internet users a trigger warning but not others, exposed everyone to one of a variety of negative materials […]" https://t.co/cjE3P2Ru5F hier wurde anscheinend nicht untersucht, ob
7| Quellen: Q1: https://t.co/gBc6jZhrqg Q2: https://t.co/8sHN0GIDOk Q3: https://t.co/TLl6C7jXN2
And it's years since all the studies came out showing that Trigger Warnings (obviously!) do more harm than good: https://t.co/fZI2g255fz https://t.co/HBoCpsYRC1 https://t.co/Dbp7nl8e1H
@HonestNauman @JeannieSGersen @anneapplebaum @NewYorker This paper includes 6 studies and an internal meta-analysis: https://t.co/gGa3nC6h1k This paper: https://t.co/4Rp1iOCljU has two direct replications: https://t.co/kpkUU9XyqZ , https://t.co/gIGgVGU8Hz
@davidbix i haven't done a super deep dive but it is plausible that they aren't effective in any meaningful way in academia, and the debate over the past decade is functionally wasted energy https://t.co/k1RPkWfO2P https://t.co/S3j3NfHLQh
I read the papers from https://t.co/7ruX9pjMFb. Those papers are: https://t.co/CNYLSOmGSy https://t.co/d9awIIxDdv (Which, "Trigger warning: Empiricial evidence ahead" is such a smarmy fucking title.)
@Kupechinikov I'll just jam the links in here since I have some breathing space: https://t.co/mR6s5ywmrM https://t.co/B27ZUhF0C2 https://t.co/uk7xHcVt5y
So there are some interesting articles linked in the above QRT on effectiveness of trigger warnings. Research suggests that Trigger Warnings don't work, and often cause an heightened anxiety on trauma-related material. https://t.co/zXpvS3ALoJ https://t.co
RT @socialepidopta: also, another fun fact for the day: they aren't helpful at the slightest; rather, they may prove to be detrimental 2)…
@Yeenie_Mcbeenie Another thing to note: https://t.co/e7b4uERxr6
also, another fun fact for the day: they aren't helpful at the slightest; rather, they may prove to be detrimental 2) https://t.co/owINMG3nkF 3-4) https://t.co/K1D3U1XEpp https://t.co/ZQ4Ji5fEie
@EffortlessFury @BriannaWu I already said it above, life doesn't come with trigger warnings. It's escapism and wishful thinking. Running away from reality doesn't change anything. https://t.co/9LqTU03D8E
@HanLovesToRead From my understanding, that's a simplification of trauma and what's required to improve accessibility. Indeed actively searching for content to avoid triggers is indicative that things already aren't going ok. https://t.co/Ayh9o9p9Ak
@sicdemo yet another study! https://t.co/x6dAQIOcBm
Ссылки из текста: https://t.co/x55yuQ8yAC https://t.co/r31goUXb3p https://t.co/U0FyfB7mTf https://t.co/VIyoKyvA6P (инглиш) Канал Yashernet.
@NoWordCount @TerichoYT "These results suggest a trigger warning is neither meaningfully helpful nor harmful." so we see the feld is really devided on it, and that it is way too few studies done to give a good and defined awnser to if it will work or not :
RT @LilMsMalditaMD: @TheDoctorLuck And another journal https://t.co/uZgNQjhVY2
@TheDoctorLuck And another journal https://t.co/uZgNQjhVY2
@a_wiglesworth Trigger Warnings Are Trivially Helpful at Reducing Negative Affect, Intrusive Thoughts, and Avoidance https://t.co/rkx0InudTd
@mikolesbian You can look through the citations if you want more information. Also this https://t.co/AQlOLRns27
@EccoZones @GeneralSyuto @theocoleridge1 @AcidGreen19 @RationalDis It is a legitimate study actually! It’s still always better to put a tw though imo https://t.co/FROh3cTaA2
Pessoal, recomendo a leitura deste artigo em Psicologia Clínica sobre o tema dos "gatilhos" (Trigger Warnings): https://t.co/CmXvLepGMA
@bixachata Recomendo a leitura deste artigo em Psicologia Clínica sobre o tema: https://t.co/CmXvLepGMA
@SavannahBoele The authors of this paper did something like you describe https://t.co/wJ0P8LKdVS
@makokaazo Didn't realize this was for class credit because you only cited your own personal experience, but okay: https://t.co/OE5GZQt2tx
@jabondcoco https://t.co/7wtxpsV2a2 Aunque entiendo que puede ser útil para un sector muy pequeño, creo que debería haber más enfoque en medidas para lidiar con el problema. Varios estudios que llegan a la conclusión de que no son tan útiles y evitan abor
@cmtyers I can’t read. 😁 Have you read this report? Fascinating. A subject that needs more research. https://t.co/Nfo6tDaU5P
@RuthAnnHarpur @maidmarian555 This study looked at video clips and came to a similar conclusion that trigger warnings don't help you to "brace" to see the video: https://t.co/iKMPKldEey
@CandaceLapan 2. The TW in our experiment is admittedly on the "extreme" end. That said, at this point several other studies have examined more "mild" trigger warnings with the same results as our study (e.g., https://t.co/iKMPKldEey)
@mindfulkoala We did not, but this paper does: https://t.co/iKMPKldEey
@zombiesrise https://t.co/bFnZFqKvn7 https://t.co/JHKoodcwnt Alas they are both paywalled. However you might find them through Google, or at the least you'll find a few articles discussing them and their results.
@lluaces @BenjaminBellet2 Not in college students, but @MevaghS had a similar condition in one of her studies. These warnings had no effect on anxiety (didn't help, didn't make things worse -- which has been the result of most TW studies to date). https://
RT @SteveStuWill: See also 👇 https://t.co/3IGH1xh8gp
RT @SteveStuWill: Trigger warnings don't work https://t.co/f2jOELASvZ https://t.co/sCpYkLtBuA
RT @SteveStuWill: See also 👇 https://t.co/3IGH1xh8gp
RT @SteveStuWill: See also 👇 https://t.co/3IGH1xh8gp
RT @SteveStuWill: See also 👇 https://t.co/3IGH1xh8gp
See also 👇 https://t.co/3IGH1xh8gp
RT @SteveStuWill: Trigger warnings don't work https://t.co/f2jOELASvZ https://t.co/sCpYkLtBuA
@islaislai There was a study this year that found trigger warning to be complete ineffective if not more harmful for people with trauma. https://t.co/E2KHcVPkEW
@that1mum There’s was literally a study this year that sound trigger warning to be either completely ineffective and sometimes and could even hurt those grappling with severe trauma https://t.co/E2KHcVPkEW
@lastpositivist Also, as per this paper mentioned in the article, given the weak signal, the degree of harm you're doing is unlikely to be high if you're wrong: https://t.co/xflky2KKYd
@LucDeanxxx The article was talking more specifically about the use of warnings within education, coming off the back of a few studies like this one: https://t.co/Ayh9o9p9Ak /1
@DisabledTimes This is a good empirical question! It was investigated by Sanson and colleagues, who found that specific content warnings were equally unhelpful for preventing anxiety: https://t.co/IoY2I992gW
@MaajidNawaz that's because trigger-warnings don't work 🥴 https://t.co/NwIjY4HU5z
RT @JulieSLalonde: Since we're on the topic of 'Things people teach on campus that are not actually effective, they just make progressives…
RT @JulieSLalonde: Since we're on the topic of 'Things people teach on campus that are not actually effective, they just make progressives…
Since we're on the topic of 'Things people teach on campus that are not actually effective, they just make progressives feel better', new research demonstrates that trigger warnings are at best, a neutral exercise. https://t.co/qlAJtm37Xo
RT @LJMeindl: Diese "Studie" ist völlig unsinnig. TWs sind dafür da um sich ENTSCHEIDEN zu können ob 1 sich damit auseinander setzen will o…
RT @LJMeindl: Diese "Studie" ist völlig unsinnig. TWs sind dafür da um sich ENTSCHEIDEN zu können ob 1 sich damit auseinander setzen will o…
RT @LJMeindl: Diese "Studie" ist völlig unsinnig. TWs sind dafür da um sich ENTSCHEIDEN zu können ob 1 sich damit auseinander setzen will o…
Diese "Studie" ist völlig unsinnig. TWs sind dafür da um sich ENTSCHEIDEN zu können ob 1 sich damit auseinander setzen will oder nicht! Diese Wahl hast du in der Studie nicht.
Particularly relevant for classroom and research contexts - Authors' findings suggest that "trigger warnings are trivially helpful at reducing negative affect, intrusive thoughts, and avoidance" #triggerwarnings https://t.co/WYth262ji7
@StefanGoetz3 Psych Science study concludes that they don't hurt or help: https://t.co/gh8suRJlRE A preprint with similar conclusions (although a bit more negative on their usefulness): https://t.co/AijrOQvg9N
@ZbeulPro En plus : https://t.co/YK5qeMWCdG
@JessStohlmann @eisenlohr_moul @kimvanorden Thoughts on studies showing TWs to be ineffective https://t.co/SUQQhQt1jL and they may countertherapeutically reinforce survivors' view of their trauma as central to their identity https://t.co/zeRlp9s3HV?
An additional study in by a different team of researches found that trigger warnings, at the very best, are not helpful. https://t.co/1LvNw4swKh https://t.co/YSAtbuAp8u
RT @tylerblack32: 1) There is important science offered ( https://t.co/JpPJ9lvE4p ), that trigger warnings do not lessen the impact of EXPO…
@SteveStuWill 63. É um campo novo, mas até agora não existem evidências de que alertas de gatilho (trigger warnings) ajudam [90] [90] https://t.co/tPIZfqFAHg
@jannypie You might like this study, which used several other outcome measures! https://t.co/Q9DwTZKp4r
@tylerblack32 @dingo_6 @conor64 My broadness in these tweets was also bolstered somewhat because of the consistency in the broader literature on TWs, which is a context many others won’t have. This study for example is a great read https://t.co/Q9DwTZKp4r
1) There is important science offered ( https://t.co/JpPJ9lvE4p ), that trigger warnings do not lessen the impact of EXPOSURE to disturbing / triggering content.
@more_coral Actually, some of the past studies (reviewed in the paper) have done that. Sanson et al (2019) is one example. I would encourage you to check it out! https://t.co/Q9DwTZKp4r
The importance of evidence-based practise: https://t.co/EdyOS46DgF